According to Microsoft’s MajorNelson, users who purchased and downloaded the DLC will have to delete that version from their storage device before downloading the new version.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c37f7/c37f7c0467db645e90c1d2807aa0f9d9983ea983" alt=""
The necessary stepts are as follows:
– Sign in to Xbox LIVE then press the guide button
– Go to Settings->System Settings->Memory.
– From here, scroll down to Fall Out 3 and press A.
– Select Fallout 3: The Pitt (Marketplace Content) press A then choose Delete, then Yes to Delete.
The Pitt DLC pack can be downloaded once again at no charge. The pack costs $10 and includes new quests, items and new area to explore: a post-apocalyptic version of Pittsburgh.